What went wrong with the forecasts?

Posted by: Duncan Orr ">Duncan Orr, on January 23, 2018.

Reading the tea leaves

Investors at year-end are inclined to reflect on the 12 months gone and muse on what the coming year might bring. Aware of this appetite for speculation, the
media tends to feed it with forecasts. These articles can be fun to read, but are even more so a year later.

In January 2017, one media outlet said Wall Street strategists were more bearish on equities than they had been for any year since 2005. The consensus forecast for the S&P 500 was for a gain in 2017 of about 4%. Individual forecasts from the 16 analysts quoted by the publication ranged from as low as 1.3% to as high as 10.1%.1

So how did that turn out? Well, by mid-December, nearly a year after those forecasts were published, the S&P500 was up by nearly 19% for the calendar year, the US market’s ninth consecutive year of gains and shaping up as its best year since 2013.

What went wrong with the forecasts?

Well, you could certainly put together a convincing case for caution in early 2017. One analyst quoted by The New York Times back in January, said investors had more risk in their portfolios than at any time since 1999.2

Stock market valuations were historically high, the analyst observed, while interest rates were rising, a new administration in Washington posed multiple uncertainties, elections were looming in France, Germany and Japan, and North Korea was sabre-rattling.

In Australia, economists were equally cautious. In a survey published in December 2016, analysts cited as uncertainties for Australia the Trump administration’s policies, Chinese demand for commodities and the course of the local property market.3

The consensus was for flat to modest gains in the local share market, a slowly depreciating Australian dollar and steady local interest rates. The results here were mixed. The S&P/ASX 300 total return to mid-December was about 10%, the Australian dollar was in fact higher over the year, while cash rates were unchanged at 1.5%.

In the UK, the FTSE-100 index was hitting successive record highs in early 2017 and there was a view in some quarters, as expressed in the UK Telegraph, that it couldn’t last given doubts over the Brexit process and looming European elections.4 Nearly a year later, the index was up more than 8% on a total return basis, having hit record highs in November.

Best performers of 2017

But the best performers of the year have been emerging markets equities, which were about 26% higher at time of writing. A pity, then, if you had followed the gloomy forecasts of analysts quoted by one newspaper, which back in early 2017 said the MSCI emerging markets index had formed a feared “death-cross” pattern, signalling a bearish trend ahead.5

So what of forecasts for 2018? 

Now, as we head into 2018, look out for a new round of market “outlooks”. Already there are sage-sounding warnings about looming geopolitical risks, the prospect of a collapse in commodity prices, rapidly rising interest rates (or falling – take your pick) and a meltdown in global credit markets.

When reading articles like these it always pays to keep in mind a few key points.

One is that all these opinions and forecasts are already reflected in prices, which reflect the aggregate view of participants about prospects for individual securities and markets generally.

A second point to keep in mind is that no forecast, however well-reasoned, can ever account for all the unexpected things that might happen. We can never eliminate uncertainty which is the trade-off we make as investors for potential increased returns.

A third observation is that prices change on new information. But what often moves prices the most are events the market didn’t expect at all. That’s why you sometimes see share prices rise on what is ostensibly bad economic news because the focus is on the fact that the data was not as bad as what was already priced in.

A final reminder is that it is pointless to chop and change your carefully designed portfolio based on the opinions of economists, strategists, journalists and other commentators.

Sometimes these people will get it right. Most of the time, they’ll be wrong.

And even if they do get the magnitude of a market move correct, they might still be off on the timing. There are just so many moving parts to make this a viable investment strategy.

A better approach is to build an appropriate asset allocation that you can live with. If you feel you can’t bear the risk, you have other options – like moderating your return expectations, working longer or spending less.

The future is uncertain. That’s the way it is.

But keep in mind that much of the noise and forecasting in the media over events in the past two years – whether it was Brexit, the US presidential election or the path of the global economy – have turned out to be wrong.

Sure, media commentary and speculation about what happens next can be interesting and thought-provoking. You can legitimately take an interest in these issues as a citizen of the world. But that doesn’t necessarily mean you should act on them as an investor.

Ultimately, what you need is an investment portfolio that is designed for you and your goals and which lets you sleep at night. Once that’s in place and you accept that the world will always be uncertain, you won’t have to waste your time reading the tea leaves.

If you have a question about investments please contact us on 01825 76 33 66 or complete a contact form.


 1‘Wall Street’s 2017 Forecast is the Most Bearish Annual Outlook in 12 years’, CNBC, 3 Jan 2017
2‘A Rising Market Now Confronts Heightened Risks’, NY Times, 13 Jan 2017
3‘What Economists Predict for 2017’, Eureka Report, 21 Dec 2016
4‘FTSE 100 Hits Successive Record Highs, But Can It Last?’, The Telegraph, 6 Jan 2017
5‘Key Indicators Suggest Emerging Markets are Heading Downwards’, The Economic Times, 16 Jan 2017


Enter your email

Get free investment, pensions and wealth management news and advice.

* indicates required

*We will never share your details with any third party.


Client Stories

Book a consultation

Your Name (required)

Email (required)

Phone Number


Employment Status


What you would like to talk about?


Enter exactly what you see above

Enter your email to receive free relevant news and updates.

* indicates required

*We will never share your details with any third party.

Latest… View all

Putting the current stock market decline in context

There’s no doubt hyperbolic headlines depicting the recent falls on the world’s financial markets are potentially anxiety-inducing. With the FTSE 100 Index falling to its lowest level since April 2017, the effect of the headlines is to promote a sense of uneasiness; we’re here to remind you that this shouldn’t be the case. Instead of […]

Read more →

Inheritance Tax is an avoidable tax

It is often said that Inheritance Tax is an avoidable tax, but many of us somehow fail to avoid it. Why is this? In our experience, clients’ failure to plan effectively is a result of the following perceived problems: Speed – How often will the thought of having to survive 7 years from the date […]

Read more →

What went wrong with the forecasts?

Reading the tea leaves Investors at year-end are inclined to reflect on the 12 months gone and muse on what the coming year might bring. Aware of this appetite for speculation, themedia tends to feed it with forecasts. These articles can be fun to read, but are even more so a year later. In January […]

Read more →

What should investors make of bitcoin mania?

Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies are receiving intense media coverage, prompting many investors to wonder whether these new types of electronic money deserve a place in their portfolios. Cryptocurrencies such as bitcoin emerged only in the past decade. Unlike traditional money, no paper notes or metal coins are involved. No central bank issues the currency, and […]

Read more →